Skip to content
Snippets Groups Projects
Unverified Commit 7da1ab26 authored by rhatto's avatar rhatto
Browse files

Updates catb and services

parent d06d921a
No related branches found
No related tags found
No related merge requests found
[[!meta title="The Cathedral & The Bazaar"]]
[[!tag jogo software foss economics]]
* [The Cathedral and the Bazaar](http://www.catb.org/~esr/writings/cathedral-bazaar/)
* Author: Eric S. Raymond
* ISBN: 978-0-596-00108-7
* Publisher: O'Reilly
## Phenomenology
......@@ -79,3 +82,56 @@ with the gift economy model:
'hierachy of values' model of human motivation.
-- 82-83
Cites both Ayn Rand and Nietzsche at page 88 when talking about "selfless"
motives, besides their "whatever other failings", saying that both
are "desconstructing" 'altruism' into unacknowledged kinds of self-interest.
## The value of humility
Furthermore, past bugs are not automatically held against a developer; the fact
that a bug has been fixed is generally considered more importante than the fact
that one used to be there. As one respontend observed, one can gain status by
fixing 'Emacs bugs', but not by fixing 'Richard Stallman's bugs' -- and it
would be considered extremely bad form to criticie Stallman for _old_ Emacs
bugs that have since been fixed.
This makes an interesting contrast with many parts of academia, in which
trashing putatively defective work by others is an important mode of gaining
reputation. In the hacker culture, such behavior is rather heavily tabooed --
so heavily, in fact, that the absence of such behavior did no present itself to
me as a datum until that one respondent with an unusual perdpective pointed it
out nearly a full year after this essay was first published!
The taboo against attacks on competence (not shared with academia) is even more
revealing than the (shared) taboo on posturing, because we can relate it to a
difference between academia and hackerdom in their communications and support
structures.
The hacker culture's medium of gifting is intangible, its communications
channels are poor at expressing emotional nuance, and face-to-face contact
among its members is the exception rather than the rule. This gives it a lower
tolerance of noise than most other gift cultures, and goes a long way to
explain both the taboo against posturing and the taboo against attacks on
competence. Any significant incidence of flames over hackers' competence would
intolerably disrupt the culture's reputation scoreboard.
-- 90-91
What about Linus behavior, then?
The same vulnerability to noise explains the model of public humility required
of the hacker community's tribal elders. They must be seen to be free of boast
and posturing so the taboo against dangerous noise will hold.
Talking softly is also functional if one aspires to be a maintainer of a
successful project; one must convince the community that one has good
judgement, because most of the maintainer's job is going to be judging other
people's code. Who would be inclined to contribute work to someone who clearly
can't judge the quality of their own code, or whose behavior suggests they will
attempt to unfairly hog the reputation return from the project? Potential
contributors want project leaders with enough humility and class to be able to
to say, when objectively appropriate, ``Yes, that does work better than my
version, I'll use it''—and to give credit where credit is due.
-- 91
......@@ -110,7 +110,7 @@ Social networking
* [Incoma](https://github.com/Incoma/Incoma).
* [Sneer](https://github.com/klauswuestefeld/sneer).
* [Noosfero](http://noosfero.org/).
* [Mastodon](https://mastodon.social) ([public instances](https://instances.mastodon.xyz/))..
* [Mastodon](https://mastodon.social) ([public instances](https://instances.mastodon.xyz/)).
* Democracia: [Liquid Democracy](https://wiki.piratenpartei.de/Liquid_Democracy) / [Liquid Feedback](http://liquidfeedback.org).
* [Briar](http://briar.sourceforge.net).
* [Twister](http://twister.net.co/).
......@@ -183,7 +183,7 @@ Office
* [COMT](http://www.co-ment.org/).
* [UNG Project](http://www.ung-project.org).
* [Libre Docs](http://libredocs.org).
* [Gitlab](http://gitlabhq.com) / [Gitorious](http://getgitorious.com) / [Gogs](http://gogs.io) / [klaus: the first Git web viewer that Just Works™.](https://github.com/jonashaag/klaus).
* [Gitlab](http://gitlabhq.com) / [Gitorious](http://getgitorious.com) / [Gogs](http://gogs.io) / [klaus: the first Git web viewer that Just Works™](https://github.com/jonashaag/klaus).
* [Teambox](http://teambox.com/) ([código](https://github.com/teambox/teambox)).
* Sobby / Infinote (gobby).
* [Pleft](https://github.com/sander/pleft) / [RdvZ](http://gpl.univ-avignon.fr/rdvz/) / [Nuages](http://nuages.domainepublic.net/nuages/) / [OpenSondage](https://github.com/leblanc-simon/OpenSondage).
......
0% Loading or .
You are about to add 0 people to the discussion. Proceed with caution.
Finish editing this message first!
Please register or to comment