diff --git a/monsters.sty b/monsters.sty
index 9fd5d5c153997a7dda90caec4d0a2e04cda188d9..72a3cd5411f3bc21fa1c02b9fe16b3c64706f3ee 100644
--- a/monsters.sty
+++ b/monsters.sty
@@ -286,6 +286,7 @@
     \setcounter{Caving}{\value{r2}}%
     \setcounter{Crafts}{\value{r2b}}%
     \setcounter{Deceit}{\value{r3}}%
+    \knacks{\ifodd\value{r3}\specialist{Appraisal}\else\specialist{Cartography}\fi}
   }
   }